Project

General

Profile

Bug #6464

Peer assessment: self subscribing in group - no other users already in groups

Added by Anneleen Verckens over 7 years ago. Updated over 7 years ago.

Status:
Needs more info
Priority:
Normal
Assignee:
Anneleen Verckens
Target version:
Chamilo LCMS Connect - LCMS 4 Beta
Start date:
18/07/2013
Due date:
% Done:

0%

Estimated time:
Complexity:
Normal

Description

http://portaal.ehb.be/evh/index.php?application=weblcms&course=8&tool=peer_assessment&go=course_viewer&tool_action=complex_display&publication=67&display_action=user_attempt_status_viewer&attempt=5

Steps taken:
- peer assessment with self-subscription to groups
- see as student - subscribing to one group
- trying to fill in an attempt while no other users subscribed to group
- red sign 'you are the only user in this group'
=> but when does a student know that the group is 'full', or that all other students are subscribed? It is possible to start filling in an attempt while not all users are already subscribed, but this should be impossible.

http://portaal.ehb.be/evh/index.php?application=weblcms&course=8&tool=peer_assessment&go=course_viewer&tool_action=complex_display&publication=67&display_action=viewer&attempt=5

Files

PA_nietalleusersingroep_tochscoresinvullen.JPG (18 KB) PA_nietalleusersingroep_tochscoresinvullen.JPG Anneleen Verckens, 18/07/2013 13:48

History

#1

Updated by Anneleen Verckens over 7 years ago

As a course manager I filled in by settings 'minimum amount of users in group: 6' (and maximum 8) - but this seems to have no effect on the fact of a student can start giving scores. Logically I should expect that a student only can give scores when the minimum of 6 is reached (but what with number 7 and 8?)

#2

Updated by Sven Vanpoucke over 7 years ago

  • Target version set to LCMS 4 Beta
#3

Updated by Jens Vanderheyden over 7 years ago

  • Status changed from New to Needs more info
  • Assignee set to Anneleen Verckens

this clearly needs more analysis
multiple options are possible

  • as soon as the first scores are given no more group subscriptions are possible
  • scores can only be given as soon as the max user amount is reached
  • the teacher has to open the scoring (and subscriptions are closed at the same time)
  • ...

all can be implemented through a setting

#4

Updated by Anneleen Verckens over 7 years ago

Most logical seems: the teacher has to open the scoring (and subscriptions are closed at the same time)

Students should not be possible to give scores when the group is not complete yet (PA is always after group work, so group should be complete before starting group work too), the first option is not save enough

#5

Updated by Jens Vanderheyden over 7 years ago

this will not be implemnted for the time being since self subscription is commented out

#6

Updated by Anneleen Verckens over 7 years ago

I thought self-subscription would still be possible, but only some changes in what you see choosing self-subscription (incl min-max group members etc) or not (no min-max group members-boxes etc). But maybe that is not possible to realize now?

Also available in: Atom PDF